| Joseph Benson GOODWIN (?1839 - 1917) |
|
| Sarah Elizabeth Clara PIPES (1870 - ) |
| Thomas CHISHOLM | Harriet Lavonia GOODWIN |
| b. abt 1896 chr. d. bur. occ. edu. rel. |
b. 4 Sep 1896, Victoria, Cumb. Co. NS19570,19571 chr. d. 1969 bur. occ. -; r. Victoria, Cumb. Co. NS (1901) edu. rel. |
| Thomas Layton CHISHOLM |